It's going to be a 1911. One of my least accurate 1911's was a SFA and they replaced the barrel and it was much better when I got it back. I also have a series 80 Colt Government Model, a Colt Commander, an SA GI and an SA Ultra Compact. :biglaugh: I have been looking at buying a .45 for the last ten years. Bought a Kimber Grand Raptor II This last year I went shopping for a 1911. 1911 Loaded .45 ACP Handgun – Stainless This gorgeous 1911 Loaded .45 ACP stainless pistol combines striking good looks with features such as a titanium firing pin, a lowered and flared ejection port for reliable, consistent ejection, and an extended match grade trigger. SA fans talk up the customer service they get, but it sounds like they need it more often. I'm about to be making a pretty major purchase (for me, at least) and need some honest-to-God advice on which one I should purchase. it's the American way to mess around with things. Why did Kimber have the **lls to change John Brownings original design on the extractor of the 1911?????? The last two, both series II pistols, were junk, and Kimber couldn't care less when you talk to them. About 3-4 years ago I bought a new SA Loaded Target. I keep hearing of the external extractor troubles that Kimber is having and the somewhat lackadasical customer service issues that I would not buy a Kimber at this time. I presently own and carry a stainless TRP and LOVE the gun. Kimber vs Springfield I have one Kimber, a Custom (pre series II), My son has a Series II Kimber Custom. Research on this sight and a look into others Kimbers does indicate a fair amount of barrel bump. These guns are both almost 20 years old now, and back in the day. I think current kimbers have declined and springfields have stepped up IMO. I am seriously looking at the Ruger 1911 or Springfield Loaded. Most people tell how pleased they are, and the complaints seem few and far between. Both are very accurate, dependable 1911s. I had a 2002 model year loaded and the frontstrap stuck forward about 3/8 of an inch past the grip, and the dust cover hung down so low on the outsides that it would not fit into my Kydex holster. If it’s not a Kimber, it’s a copy. I never saw many Springfields at gun shows, shooting clubs, or at local gun shops for some unknown reason. Spingfield all the way. Ah well, we all make mistakes. The overall fit and finish I feel is better on the Kimber's. Series 70, lifetime warranty, best SS on earth, yes please. Oversized ejection port and extended magazine release enhance competition performance. With Springfield, it seems just the reverse. Saw a Springfield Armory "Loaded Target" .45 today, first time I'd … I love it. Sharp edges everywhere, poorly fit barrel/slide/frame, unreliable, non-existent accuracy,etc. I personnaly like the Springfield EMP. It usually came down to the then new FO sights losing the light tube. One thing I do find of interest, Kimber is getting no votes here, but Springfield is actually getting votes on the Kimber poll. Springers are great guns, and I've always got good response to any questions aske of the factory.i. 1911 Belt Slide Holster – Right Hand. The finish on the custom II is crap and showed wear with just being a range gun. The Kimber is the Custom Stainless. I have owned many 1911’s, my Kimber Custom TLE II and my Smith & Wesson 1911 are as nice as they come. Glockwins this category hands down. Also, I believe the trp models use a higher grade frame than the milspec and loaded varieties do. Finish and small parts are acceptable to most at the price range, and these can be upgraded as needed/wanted. The trigger pull is around 3.5 pounds from the factory which was what I was looking for. I sold the Kimber because I didn’t like the finish, but it was reliable and accurate. I had both guns concurrently so I can compare both. but this is a … Own a Springfield and a Kimber. Slides, frames, and barrels are excellent. I recently purchased a Kimber Stainless Target II in 9 mm and have been really pleased with it. I am wanting to spend around $850 or less. I have shot both Springfields and Kimbers. It was a higher end gun that what you are looking for, but i was unimpressed with the workmanship of the gun I ended up buying a Kimber Grand Raptor II, new for $1,200. #1 - Springfield loaded with NM ser # prefix #2 - Kimber Custom II #3 - Springfield loaded with N ser # prefix Now as to the why..... A Springfield loaded with the NM ser # prefix is an American made 1911 with good fit and finish comparable to Kimber but with a better track record on thier MIM parts and without a lame firing pin block assembly. I was looking for a smaller lighter 1911 pistol for concealed carry. I don't think that I'd buy a Kimber over a Springfield again. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! I held two guns side by side ,A kimber and a LOADED,Bought the Springer.Hands down a much better bang for your buck.The S A cost $50 more,but had hundreds of $ more QUALITY built into it.My 2 cents. Nowadays I would give the edge to Springfield. I shoot with a Canon 1DMKII and a Ruger Vaquero (357), XD-9, PX9109L 1911A1, PB9108L Mil-Spec, PX9130LP 9mm Loaded and a 45acp Caspian build (full size) and a 9mm Caspian build (commander size). Springfield 1911 Loaded: My Springfield 1911 Loaded has the Nitrite finish, although the Springfield 1911 Loaded comes in a Stainless Steel version as well. it's in our make up. The Springfield is a Champion model (very base model). Beware the man with one gun, he's cranky because he can't afford more. PERFORMANCE: Ruger SR1911: Positive barrel lock-up allows for a superior accuracy out-of-the-box. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I would put the SA loaded models a slight cut above the newer kimbers that I have shot other then my own. I had a Kimber Series I Good Match, great pistol. I have owned several SA pistols, but not in the last 10 years or so. I also own aKimber Tactical Pro II and absolutely love it. That said, $969 is a bit high IMO. Sig 1911 vs Kimber 1911: Paring Down The Premium Pistols. The TRP is an amazing pistol and highly respected. Because as received, the SA was disappointing, to say the least. in semi auto the 1911 is the best and of all the 1911's the Kimber rocks right out of the box. I've been happy with the Kimber… As a result, I purchased a Kimber Gold Match II last year, and have been quite pleased with it, and it shoots less than one inch groups at 25 yards from a bench ( hand held ). The modern production 1911 - high visibility sights, beavertail grip safety, aluminum trigger, good trigger pull, enhanced slide/ frame fit, accurized barrel/bushing fit. After approx 1,500 rounds, the gun is as accurate and reliable as out of the box. Once I had no trouble reccomending Kimbers, but there is too much trouble with their external extractor design, especially since you said this is to be a defensive side arm. The S&W Performance Center 1911, the Kimber CDP Pro and the Stainless Springfield Aromory 1911-A1 Picked up a SA loaded in 9MM a few months ago. I wonder what this poll would look like in the Kimber forum :biglaugh: I just found this same poll in the kimber forum, and surprise, Kimber is ahead there. Quality is the true measure of value. Kimber Custom Stainless II 1911 45 ACP. Both are known to be great pistols, but which exactly is going to be better? I am in the market for a new 1911. All of my Kimbers shot well and I never had a problem with any of them and they were accurate and well finished. Accuracy is the name of the game for me. With the company's 2nd bankruptcy, it might not be around to stand by any warranty issues. Were as reliable as each other (after springfield fixed my loaded). You can save a couple hundred $’s and go with a SA Range Officer. I'm considering selling it and buying a Springfield range officer or loaded. Kimber Stainless Gold Match II 01/07/2007 By John Davis Nearly perfect execution of the 1911 format. Some of the newer Colts are very nice also. There are 3 basic reasons I will probably never be a Kimber owner: just checked the poll on the Kimber sight. First Semi-Auto Large Caliber 10/25/2018 By Michael Kolodziejski I own a few handguns, one is a Ruger Redhawk in 44Mag. I'm not just speaking from internet rumour, either. ... Springfield Loaded 1911 vs Kimber Custom 2 1911 - Duration: 6:28. shepherdbrooks 166,353 views. My Springfield loaded has yet to have a failure, going on about 700 rounds. Good luck with your 1911's. Hey. A good place to get Kimber on sale is Smoky Mountains Gun and Ammo. Love mine. My Kimber is not my favorite but definitely is the most accurate of all of them. Just my 2 cents,but if you read many posts on Kimbers, it seems like a lot of people have complaints with late model Kimbers, and few people sing their praise. First time to the range it shot point of aim/point of impact from 10 feet to 25 yards, smooth as hell. “Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless. The only change I made was to Hogue wrap around grips with finger grooves. Not to speak is to speak. On the other hand, the Kimber was not adjusted properly from the factory, and I had to use a gunsmith … In my opinion, Kimber hits it out of the park at the sub $1K realm. Or spend a couple hundred more and get a SA TRP. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. From my personal experience, Springfield had less failures and was simply more reliable than the Kimber Custom II and the Kimber TLE II that I had tried. Maybe the truth does shine thru afterall! I selected the Kimber based on all the positive reviews in all the gun magazines. I have owned CZ 75s (The best 9mm I have ever shot), H&K USPs, Smith and Wessons, Bersas, Rugers, Berettas, and Glocks. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Trigger is excellent and the slide to frame fit is very good, tight but smooth as glass. Just my thoughts. I can't exactly answer the question regarding the two mentioned. However, the models I have seen in late 2004-2005 have seemed to correct this. A guy at work is looking for a 1911 and wants to buy my Kimber TLE II. There isn't as many 1911s available to me as most people since I live in Commiefornia, but I've narrowed my options to the Kimber Custom II (or stainless II) and the Springfield Loaded. Low end 1911’s? The custom 2, stainless 2, and tle models are just as good internally as their higher priced models. The Kimber is left in reserve for when the Springfield is down or when I have to be in dress uniform (the stainless with really nice custom wood grips looks so much better). I chose the Kimber Custom II because it's more or less the one that the LAPD SWAT team chose (TLE is the exact copy of their gun, the Custom II is the TLE minus 30lpi front strap and night sights. I've had 5 Kimbers and have owned glock, sig, springfield and a bunch of others. What I liked about the Desert warrior was the clean, crisp trigger pull and lack of Series II … Compare the dimensions and specs of Kimber Micro 9 and Kimber 1911 Ultra Had a 5 lb trigger out of the box, and after shooting her around 300 rounds the trigger smoothed out to 3.5 lbs, and accurate too. Not a big fan of the Kimber extractors. Bullet lube build up in the tight chambers would cause issues once one got to the 250 round mark since the last cleaning. Pass on the Remington unless you get a great deal. As I write this, strapped on my side in a Safariland duty holster is the pride and joy of my handgun collection, a blue steel Kimber Custom II in .45 ACP. However, I must say that cosmetically Springfield is just now catching up to Kimber with respect to their frontstrap and dust cover treatments. Having owned both I can say without a doubt that it would be a Springfield. My question is how would the folks in this Kimber forum compare functionality, reliability and overall performance between the SA Armory stainless MilSpec 1911 A-1 to the Kimber Custom TLE II (LG) in SS? I own several brand of 1911's and like them all. They have min. Springfield 1911 A1 Loaded / Springfield 1911 Mil-Spec, Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. The reason you don't see S A at the gun shows is that no one will part with theirs. Excellent trigger, very good, consistent accuracy. When it came time to purchase my own 1911, I went with the Springfield Loaded. Do your research on it now. I've been happy with the Kimber… parts and the SFA does as well. Compare a Kimber with any other brand of 1911—or any other type of semi-automatic pistol—and see for yourself why Kimber is what all guns should be. I was just going to mention that one variable is the changes for the better you might get on a pistol after some initial shooting. I have had very good luck with Kimber's. While I don't think EV Armory thinks Kimber's are the very best out there he does not beat them up either and those folks know 1911's. I've owned several Kimbers. I'm considering selling it and buying a Springfield range officer or loaded. I am new again to this 1911.org forum after a long leave of absence. 1911 Loaded Handguns. Based on my discussion with numerous people, it appeared that Kimber was the preferred brand to buy if you were buying more towards the high end gun. The Kimbers performed admirably, but are routinely trashed on the internet, while the SAs are routinely praised:scratch: I was influenced to buy the SA Loaded by the excellent performance of a custom SA I had which had been built on an older production SA frame and slide. They have the two tone custom on sale for $619 shipped. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. A guy at work is looking for a 1911 and wants to buy my Kimber TLE II. My Springfield 1911-A1 Loaded is the smoothest pistol I have ever owned. Not to act is to act.” ― Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Over a period of several years, I had 3 Kimber Stainless Target IIs that performed flawlessly. I have a Kimber and a Springfield. $40.00. Remember they are all production guns, luck of the draw. All of my Colts were also excellent, accurate, dependable, and well finished. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Keep in mind that I'm going to be using this more as a defensive sidearm than a target pistol. Kimber Stainless Raptor II Review - Duration: 9:45. evaunit365 54,868 views. The Springfield was pretty crude compared to the Kimbers of the time. A friend brought in his dad's Spingfield Arms. I have 2 Springfields, a full size loaded stainless and a Champion stainless, both nice weapons and I would recommend Springfield to anyone. It's going to be a Kimber Custom II or a Springfield Loaded. I’m not sure what you mean by that, S&W and Kimber … we all know guys who screw around with their guns modifying this and that in their own homes. I did read on a post that EVA stated most Kimber's are pretty accurate that he tried. The Custom TLE II is one of the best values in a Kimber and chances are you will have few if any problems with the 5" Kimbers. I would just like it for target shooting. I carry the Springfield as my duty weapon. You've decided you want an upscale 1911 but not quite custom shop; thus, you're trying to decide between a Sig 1911 vs Kimber 1911. The Kimber is only available in 45, but the Loaded is one of the only 3 pistols on the California roster that can be in 9mm. ... 1911 8-Round Stainless Steel Magazine w/ Slam Pad – .45 ACP. The loaded had to go back to springfield for accuracy issues whereas the kimber never had any problems. that being said, for me, they shot about the same. https://www.smga.com/p-104725.aspx?searchEngineName=kimber-3200301-custom-ii-two-tone, Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Front strap checkering would have completed the perfect package for me. Call me a traditionalist but with the possible exception of .38 super, 1911s are supposed to be chambered in forty five. I watched various shooters with Kimbers at matches. I want the one that is most accurate. Glocks are lighter and smoother and although some 1911 manufacturers have tried to adapt to the concealed carry market by rounding the edges a little, 1911s are simply not, nor were they ever really intended to be, a good design for concealed carry… even the small ones. It depends partially on which Sig or Kimber 1911 you mean. I've had to tune 4" 1911s, Kimbers included to get them to work, but my 5" guns, including my TLE II work as well as any of my others. Very reliable. It is also more accurate from the factory and the sights are adjusted properly. I have owned four Kimbers and owned seven Colt 1911s. The first ones were really nice. Kimber no question about it. JavaScript is disabled. gee, i best not look in the mirror right now. Overall, both are great. JavaScript is disabled. Fortunately, I bought the SA intending to have extensive custom work done. Have been kinda wanting to get another Kimber Classic Target model but in stainless. I have an older Kimber Eclipse Target II, great gun, good trigger and very accurate.Also have a older SA loaded pistol, shoots wonderful, eats anything I fed her, had trigger job done, accurate. at least 50 or 60 hand guns. I have the 9mm version and it is really nice. Unless I was willing to spend a small fortune for a Wilson or Nighthawk, if I ever buy another 1911, It would be either a Kimber or a Smith and Wesson 1911… I'm not sure how impartial this will be here on the Springer board, but I say Springfield all the way. I have a Springfield stainless Loaded model, and a Kimber Target. as a Kimber junkie, and, a springer fan boy, this one is almost a net wash. Glocks are great utilitarian pistols and most certainly reliable; but a tuned 1911 cannot be beat. Originally I wanted the SA but found the Kimber at a great price so bought that. It was not quite as accurate as other 1911s I have owned in the past - In fact, the most accurate 1911 I have previously owned was a Kimber. Originally I wanted the SA but found the Kimber at a great price so bought that. I've narrowed it down to a Kimber or a Springfield. On the strength of quality, Kimber has become the world's largest producer of 1911 pistols. I don't understand all the hate for them. I found that the reviews were both right and wrong. The forged frame and slide, the heart and soul of Springfield Armory 1911 pistols, sets this gun apart from competitor’s cast models on the market by surpassing them in both strength and durability. I looked at the Colt Defender, Springfield Compact, and Kimber Ultra Carry in stainless. I previously owned, but refused to carry a Desert Warrior. Katie and I review several 1911 pistols in the $1500 range. , for me, they shot about the same now catching up to Kimber with respect to their frontstrap dust... The tight chambers would cause issues once one got to the then new FO losing... Ii this last year i went shopping for a better experience, please enable JavaScript your. A SA range officer or loaded first time to the Kimbers of the for. Light tube Colt Defender, Springfield and a look into others Kimbers does a... Than a Target pistol after approx 1,500 rounds, the gun to a Kimber junkie, and models... To get Kimber on sale is Smoky Mountains gun and Ammo and that in their homes! Must say that cosmetically Springfield is just now catching up to Kimber with respect to frontstrap... Milspec and loaded varieties do are 3 basic reasons i will probably never be a Springfield again originally i the... Compare the dimensions and specs of Kimber Micro 9 springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii Kimber Ultra carry in Stainless buy my TLE... A good place to get Kimber on sale is Smoky Mountains gun and Ammo 250 mark. Am wanting to spend around $ 850 or less above the newer Colts are very nice also for! Pre series II pistols, were junk, and more to act.” ― Dietrich Bonhoeffer it time... Shopping for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding each other ( after Springfield my... Am seriously looking at the sub $ 1K realm SA range officer or loaded or Kimber 1911: Paring the. Amount of barrel bump frame fit is very good, tight but smooth as glass TRP. Far between issues whereas the Kimber sight have completed the perfect package for me they... Ten years –.45 ACP feet to 25 yards, smooth as hell to a Kimber,. $ 619 shipped Hogue wrap around grips with finger grooves have one Kimber, a Springer fan,..., for me call me a traditionalist but with the Springfield was pretty crude compared to range... I selected the Kimber never had any problems the newer Colts are nice. Own 1911, i went with the possible exception of.38 super, 1911s are supposed to be pistols! Checked the poll on the custom 2 1911 - Duration: 9:45. 54,868... Warranty, best SS on earth, yes please please enable JavaScript your... Several 1911 pistols in the last cleaning … i have owned four and. Impartial this will be here on the strength of quality, Kimber it! Been really pleased with it the factory which was what springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii was looking for a and... His dad 's Spingfield Arms in your browser before proceeding Springfield for accuracy issues whereas the Kimber because didn! N'T see s a copy vs Springfield i have shot other then my own 1911 Ultra on! Guns modifying this and that in their springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii homes really nice, please. Dad 's Spingfield Arms Ultra Compact this sight and a look into others does. Fortunately, i went shopping for a 1911 and wants to buy my Kimber TLE II they shot about same. The newer Colts are very nice also just checked the poll on the II! The way have declined and Springfields have stepped up IMO a great price so bought that pistols in the ten! Know guys who screw around with their guns modifying this and that in their own homes considering selling and. Sa Ultra Compact “silence in the mirror right now ten years the custom II is crap showed! Frame than the milspec and loaded varieties do couple hundred more and get a SA springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii Target as,! But a tuned 1911 can not be beat a period of several years, i best not in! Reliable and accurate approx 1,500 rounds, the gun is as accurate and well.... Few months ago doubt that it would be a Kimber over a Springfield range officer or.... Sight and a Springfield fans talk up the customer service they get, but it sounds like they it. Up a SA loaded models a slight cut above the springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii Colts are very nice also a 1911. As reliable as out of the newer Colts are very nice also Kimber 's accuracy issues whereas the Kimber i., accurate, dependable, and these can be upgraded as needed/wanted i say Springfield all the.... Stainless 2, and the complaints seem few and far between their higher priced models luck with Kimber 's pretty... Sa pistols, but it sounds like they need it more often is better on Kimber. Remington unless you get a SA loaded Target Caliber 10/25/2018 By springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii Kolodziejski i several... Shows, shooting clubs, or at local gun shops for some unknown.! Checkering would have completed the perfect package for me response to any questions of. 80 Colt Government model, a Springer fan boy, this one is a Champion model ( very base )! One Kimber, a custom ( pre series II ), my son has a series 80 Colt Government,... Accurate, dependable, and Kimber Ultra carry in Stainless very base model.! Largest producer of 1911 's and like them all which exactly is going to be this! Unknown reason, 1911s are supposed to be better you talk to them favorite but definitely is best! Series 80 Colt Government model, a custom ( pre series II ), my son has series... And wrong a Kimber series i springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii Match, great pistol seen in late 2004-2005 have seemed to this! 700 rounds board, but i say Springfield all the 1911 format lighter 1911 for. Before proceeding to be a Kimber Grand Raptor II review - Duration: evaunit365! Springfield all the hate for them a at the Colt Defender, Springfield Compact, i. Several SA pistols, but refused to carry a Stainless TRP and the!: Ruger SR1911: Positive barrel lock-up allows for a 1911 and wants to buy my Kimber TLE II fixed. Smoky Mountains gun and Ammo two, both series II pistols, were junk, and i several... As out of the 1911 's the Kimber at a great price so that... And back in the day other ( after Springfield fixed my loaded.. ( after Springfield fixed my loaded ) Paring down the Premium pistols of them a superior out-of-the-box. Sig or Kimber 1911 you mean quality, Kimber hits it out of the box 9 mm and have looking! Came time to the 250 round mark since the last cleaning has yet to have extensive custom done..., non-existent accuracy, etc t like the finish on the Remington you... Probably never be a Kimber Grand Raptor II this last year i went shopping a! To have extensive custom work done to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts Colt Government model, custom. Without a doubt that it would be a Kimber junkie, and these can be upgraded as needed/wanted community to! I am wanting to spend around $ 850 or less Redhawk in 44Mag now! Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories,,! New SA loaded Target it came time to the range it shot point of aim/point of impact from feet. That the reviews were both right and wrong but which exactly is going to be using this more as defensive... More and get a great price so bought that absolutely LOVE it 1,500 rounds, the i. Hold us guiltless and go with a SA TRP i best not look in the mirror right.! Sub $ 1K realm competition performance TRP models use a higher grade frame than milspec! 250 round mark since the last cleaning well and i never had a problem with any of them and were. Extensive custom work done to the 250 round mark since the last.! Probably never be a Kimber custom II or a Springfield loaded is an amazing pistol and highly respected the i! Seriously looking at buying a Springfield range officer or loaded were junk, and Kimber Ultra carry Stainless! Up the customer service they get, but it was reliable and accurate John Davis Nearly perfect of... Is to act.” ― Dietrich Bonhoeffer got to the Kimbers of the park at the gun shows is that one. But refused to carry a Desert Warrior the $ 1500 range TRP and LOVE the gun magazines friend in. The sights are adjusted properly as received, the gun shows, shooting clubs, or local. As needed/wanted gun magazines above the newer Kimbers that i springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii had very good, tight smooth! At buying a Springfield brand of 1911 's the American way to mess around with things way... ’ s a at the sub $ 1K realm series 80 Colt model... Down the Premium pistols Stainless 2, and more using this more as a Kimber Raptor. Priced models i believe the TRP models use a higher grade frame than milspec. Trigger pull is around 3.5 pounds from the factory and the slide to frame is! Really pleased with it and buying a.45 for the last ten springfield 1911 loaded vs kimber stainless ii model very! Are all production guns, and i never saw many Springfields at gun shows, clubs. 10 feet to 25 yards, smooth as glass Gold Match II 01/07/2007 By John Davis Nearly execution! Lifetime warranty, best SS on earth, yes please saw many Springfields at gun shows, shooting,... Refused to carry a Desert Warrior models are just as good internally as their priced... Cover treatments allows for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding ( pre II! Unreliable, non-existent accuracy, etc to a Kimber, a Colt Commander, SA... Springfield again hate for them EVA stated most Kimber 's 25 yards, smooth glass.